Best Pet Insurance Companies & Plans
in New York

Examine thoughtfully selected top-rated pet insurance companies in NY that provide cost-effective plans with comprehensive coverage for your pets.

Embrace pet insurance review
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.6 / 5

Embrace Pet Health Insurance

Embrace offers a variety of pet insurance plans for both dogs and cats, including distinct Wellness Rewards and options for older pets. Recognized for its tailored policies, Embrace allows pet owners to select deductibles, reimbursement percentages, and coverage limits, focusing on adaptability and affordability. Embrace is not just about insurance; it also offers straightforward claim processes and attentive customer support, dedicated to the health of your pet.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $35
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $18
  • Maximum annual coverage – Unlimited
  • Deductible – $100 to $1,000
  • Max age limit – 14 years

read expert review Β»

Spot pet insurance review
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.5 / 5

Spot Pet Health Insurance

Spot earns a 4.5-star rating for its comprehensive pet insurance solutions for dogs and cats. Their plans include various levels of accident, illness, and preventive care. Spot’s plans are flexible, offering different options for deductibles, limits, and reimbursements, and they even cover alternative treatments. Suitable for pets of all ages, Spot is known for efficient claim handling and excellent customer support, emphasizing the health and contentment of pets.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $54
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $23
  • Maximum annual coverage – Unlimited
  • Deductible – $100, $250, $500, $750, and $1,000
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

FIGO Pet Insurance Review
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.5 / 5

FIGO Pet Health Insurance

FIGO’s pet insurance is rated 4.5 stars and offers three levels of accident-and-illness coverage, backed by innovative technology. They cover a wide range of conditions, and their Figo Pet Cloud app simplifies claim submissions and policy management. Noteworthy features include no age restrictions for enrollment and the option for 100% reimbursement. FIGO is centered around fast reimbursements and flexible options, aiding pet owners in efficiently managing pet healthcare.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $29
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $17
  • Maximum annual coverage – $5,000 to unlimited
  • Deductible – $100 to $750
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Fetch pet-insurance review
four star review

Overall Rating 4.4 / 5

Fetch Pet Health Insurance

Fetch’s pet insurance plan, rated at 4.4 stars, offers inclusive coverage for dogs and cats, spanning from accident protection to holistic care. Their policy is comprehensive, allowing use with any licensed vet in the U.S. or Canada and covering advanced treatments. Fetch provides flexible options for deductibles, limits, and reimbursements, and is known for its user-friendly application process and holistic approach to pet healthcare.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $35
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $20
  • Maximum annual coverage – $15,000
  • Deductible – $250 to $500
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Pets Best Pet Health Insurance
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.3 / 5

Pets Best Pet Health Insurance

Pets Best, with a 4.3-star rating, offers budget-friendly, diverse insurance plans for both dogs and cats. They specialize in accident and illness coverage and cater to older pets with their senior-friendly options. Their policies are customizable, offering various deductibles, reimbursement rates, and limits. Pets Best is committed to the wellness of pets, ensuring an efficient claims process and excellent service.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $30
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $28
  • Maximum annual coverage – $2,500, $5,000, $10,000 or unlimited
  • Deductible – $50 to $1,000
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Trupanion Pet Insurance Review
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.3 / 5

Trupanion Pet Health Insurance

Trupanion, boasting a 4.3-star rating, provides a distinctive pet insurance solution with direct payments to veterinarians and no cap on claims. It covers a broad spectrum of issues, from accidents and illnesses to hereditary conditions for both dogs and cats. Trupanion’s plan is especially beneficial for chronic conditions due to its lifetime per-condition deductible and typically offers 90% reimbursement. With a focus on pet-centric care, Trupanion stands out for its 24/7 customer support and a straightforward approach to pet insurance, though it excludes wellness and preventive care.

 

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $70
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $40
  • Maximum annual coverage – Unlimited
  • Deductible – $0 to $1,000
  • Max age limit – 14 years

read expert review Β»

Lemonade pet insurance review
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.2 / 5

Lemonade Pet Health Insurance

Rated 4.2 stars, Lemonade Pet Insurance merges modern technology with cost-effective coverage for both dogs and cats. They offer fundamental accident and illness plans with optional wellness extensions. Lemonade is distinguished by its socially conscious approach, donating unclaimed funds to charities. Their plans are flexible, featuring rapid claim settlements through an app and allowing policyholders to adjust deductibles, rates, and coverage limits, including preventive care and extra coverage options.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $31
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $17
  • Maximum annual coverage – $100,000
  • Deductible – $100, $250, $500
  • Max age limit – 14 years

read expert review Β»

Pumpkin Pet Insurance
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.2 / 5

Pumpkin Pet Health Insurance

Pumpkin Pet Insurance, rated at 4.2 stars, offers wide-ranging coverage that includes dental care, behavioral issues, hereditary conditions, and some pre-existing conditions. Their inclusive accident and illness plan feature unique benefits like alternative therapies and prescription diet supplements. With standard deductibles and a uniform 90% reimbursement rate, Pumpkin caters to a variety of budgets. The absence of upper age limits and a preventive care add-on highlight its commitment to comprehensive, proactive pet wellness.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $109
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $61
  • Maximum annual coverage – Unlimited
  • Deductible – $100, $250, $500, or $1,000
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Healthy Paws pet insurance review
star reviews 4.5

Overall Rating 4.2 / 5

Healthy Paws Pet Health Insurance

With a 4.2-star rating, Healthy Paws Pet Insurance delivers straightforward, cost-effective, and comprehensive coverage without annual or lifetime caps. Their simple plan is complemented by a 30-day money-back guarantee, prioritizing customer satisfaction. While not as customizable for older pets, the plan’s simplicity and clarity are key advantages. Committed to pet wellness, Healthy Paws offers efficient claims handling via a mobile app and direct vet payment facilities, recognized for its reliability by the Better Business Bureau.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $72
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $36
  • Maximum annual coverage – $5,000
  • Deductible – $250 or $500 (under 6 years)
    $500-$1,000 (6 years and older)
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

ASPCA Pet Insurance Review
four star review

Overall Rating 4.0 / 5

ASPCA Pet Health Insurance

ASPCA Pet Health Insurance, rated 4.0 stars and in collaboration with Crum and Forster since 2006, offers tailored insurance plans focusing on accidents, illnesses, and genetic conditions. Unique to ASPCA is the coverage for veterinary exam fees and microchipping. They provide flexible deductibles, rates, and coverage limits, along with a 10% discount for multiple pets and optional wellness plans. Committed to pet wellness, ASPCA supports pet owners with a 24/7 telehealth line and permits visits to any licensed vet in the US or Canada.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $36
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $16
  • Maximum annual coverage – $10,000
  • Deductible – $100 to $500
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Metlife Pet Insurance
four star review

Overall Rating 4.0 / 5

Metlife Pet Health Insurance

MetLife Pet Insurance, holding a 4.0-star rating, delivers extensive, customizable insurance options for dogs and cats, encompassing accidents, illnesses, chronic and hereditary conditions, and even alternative treatments. Known for its legacy in the industry and affordable rates, MetLife offers versatile plans that allow pet owners to choose deductibles, reimbursement rates, and coverage limits. Focusing on a seamless insurance experience, MetLife merges efficient claims handling with responsive customer support, concentrating on the overall well-being of pets.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – Β $30
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $17
  • Maximum annual coverage – $10,000
  • Deductible – $50 to $2,500
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Many Pets Pet Insurance Review
four star review

Overall Rating 4.0 / 5

ManyPets Pet Health Insurance

ManyPets Pet Insurance, with a 4.0-star rating, provides unique insurance coverage for both dogs and cats, addressing accidents, illnesses, and wellness care. It stands out by covering pre-existing conditions, a feature often excluded by others. With competitive pricing and user-friendly policies, ManyPets minimizes waiting periods for switchers and does not increase premiums after a claim. As a wellness ally, it offers seamless claim processing and attentive service, positioning itself as a valuable choice for comprehensive, hassle-free pet insurance.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $30
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $25
  • Maximum annual coverage – Unlimited
  • Deductible – $250, $500
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

WAGMO pet insurance review
four star review

Overall Rating 3.9 / 5

Wagmo Pet Health Insurance

Wagmo pet insurance, rated 3.9 stars, blends traditional accident and illness coverage with distinctive wellness plans, addressing a broad range of pet care needs. These plans make preventive care more attainable and affordable. Wagmo provides flexibility in customizing deductibles, reimbursement rates, and coverage limits, enhancing the versatility of pet insurance. Emphasizing a partnership in pet wellness, Wagmo offers efficient claims processing and strong customer support, simplifying the management of insurance and ensuring pet health and happiness.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $49
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $28
  • Maximum annual coverage – up to $20,000*
  • Deductible – $250, $500, $1,000
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Prudent Pet Insurance Review
three and half starts

Overall Rating 3.8 / 5

Prudent Pet Health Insurance

Prudent Pet Insurance, rated 3.8 stars, provides comprehensive and customizable coverage for dogs and cats. It offers a range of plans, including accident and illness, and accident-only options. Known for its customer-focused approach and flexibility, Prudent Pet allows pet owners to personalize deductibles, reimbursement levels, and coverage limits. With competitive pricing and a straightforward claims process, Prudent Pet aims to make pet insurance accessible and stress-free, supporting the wellness of pets and their families.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $45
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $40
  • Maximum annual coverage – $5,000 or unlimited
  • Deductible – $50, $100, $200, $250, $500 or $1000
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Hartville Pet Insurance Review
three and half starts

Overall Rating 3.8 / 5

Hartville Pet Health Insurance

Hartville Pet Insurance, with a 3.8-star rating, offers a wide array of comprehensive, customizable plans for dogs and cats, covering accidents, illnesses, and preventive care. They provide various options for adjusting deductibles, reimbursement rates, and coverage limits, accommodating different budgets and needs. Hartville’s emphasis on affordability and adaptability, particularly with wellness add-ons, makes them a supportive partner in pet health. They ensure an easy-to-use claims process and dedicated customer service, prioritizing the well-being of pets.

  • Average monthly cost for dogs – $49
  • Average monthly cost for cats – $28
  • Maximum annual coverage – $10,000
  • Deductible – $100, $250 or $500
  • Max age limit – No limit

read expert review Β»

Understanding Pet Insurance in New York

Pet insurance in the Empire State is a critical aspect of pet care, addressing the diverse needs of pets across New York’s varied landscapes. From the bustling streets of New York City to the serene beauty of the Adirondacks, from the historic charm of Albany to the shores of Long Island, pet insurance is an essential tool for pet owners.

Like human health insurance, pet insurance in New York is crucial for handling unforeseen veterinary costs and ensuring that your pets receive necessary care during sickness, injury, or health complications. It plays a significant role in managing these costs, providing peace of mind whether in the urban settings of Manhattan or the peaceful neighborhoods of Westchester County.

Why Consider Pet Insurance in NY

Opting for cat and dog insurance in New York offers several benefits to pet owners:

  • Financial Security: Pet insurance acts as a financial safety net, helping you deal with unexpected veterinary expenses without excessive burden.
  • Access to High-Quality Care: It ensures that your pets can receive excellent healthcare services, including advanced treatments and surgeries, without the stress of high costs.
  • Customizable Plans: You can tailor your policy to suit your pet’s specific needs and your financial capacity, choosing from a variety of coverage levels and deductible options.
  • Peace of Mind: Knowing that you can afford necessary medical care makes health decisions for your pet easier and less financially driven.
  • Encourages Regular Health Checks: Policies covering routine and preventive care promote regular veterinarian visits, leading to early detection and management of health issues.
  • Support for Ongoing Conditions: For pets with chronic health issues, pet insurance makes continuous treatment more manageable over your pet’s life.

How Pet Insurance Works in NY

Pet insurance in New York operates much like human health insurance. It provides financial coverage for your pet’s medical expenses, whether for routine check-ups, emergencies, or chronic health problems.

You typically pay your vet directly and then file a claim with your insurance provider for reimbursement based on the specifics of your coverage. Pet insurance involves paying a monthly or annual premium for your chosen plan, which will define the extent of coverage, including deductibles, reimbursement rates, and coverage limits.

Coverage options range from comprehensive plans that include accidents, illnesses, and preventive care to more specific scenarios. Understanding these details is crucial when choosing the right insurance plan to align with your pet’s needs and financial situation.

Choosing the Right Pet Insurance Company in New York

When looking for a pet insurance provider in New York, consider these factors:

  • Assess Your Pet’s Health Needs: Consider your pet’s health risks based on age, breed, and existing health conditions to identify their insurance needs.
  • Research and Compare Insurers: Investigate insurance companies’ reputations and customer feedback. Compare their policies in terms of coverage, exclusions, and restrictions.
  • Understand Policy Details and Costs: Be clear about what each policy covers and its costs, including deductibles, co-pays, and potential discounts.
  • Flexibility and Customer Support: Look for insurers that offer customizable policies and evaluate the quality of their customer service. Consider any additional benefits they might provide.
  • Balanced Decision-Making: Consider trial periods and choose a plan that balances immediate needs with long-term care considerations for your pet.

Selecting the appropriate insurance for your dog or cat in New York means safeguarding their well-being, whether navigating NYC’s fast-paced lifestyle or enjoying the quieter, rural areas upstate. It’s about ensuring your pet’s health and peace of mind across New York’s diverse and vibrant settings.

Frequently Asked Questionsβ“πŸ™‹

What is pet insurance and how does it work in New York?

Pet insurance is a type of insurance policy that covers your pet’s medical and health-related expenses. In New York, it works by you paying for veterinary services upfront and then submitting a claim to your insurer for reimbursement, based on your plan’s coverage.

What is a deductible, and how does it affect my pet insurance?

A deductible is an amount you pay out-of-pocket before your insurance coverage kicks in. A higher deductible usually means a lower premium, and vice versa.

Why should I consider getting pet insurance in NY?

Pet insurance helps manage unexpected veterinary expenses, ensures access to quality healthcare for your pet, and provides peace of mind knowing you can afford necessary treatments.

What types of pet insurance plans are available in New York?

There are typically comprehensive plans that cover accidents, illnesses, and preventive care, as well as more specific plans that might cover only accidents or illnesses.

How do I choose the right pet insurance plan in New York?

Consider your pet’s health needs, compare plans from different insurers, understand the coverage details, and choose a plan that balances your financial capacity with the care your pet needs.

How do I file a claim with my pet insurance company?

Typically, you pay the vet bill upfront, then submit a claim to your insurance company along with any required documentation. The company then reimburses you according to your plan’s terms.

Can I get pet insurance for a cat or dog with a chronic condition?

Yes, but the condition might be considered a pre-existing condition and may not be covered. It’s important to review the policy details regarding chronic conditions.

What should I do if my pet insurance claim is denied?

Review the reason for the denial to ensure it aligns with your policy terms. If you believe the claim was wrongly denied, you can appeal the decision with your insurance company.

Can I cancel my pet insurance policy at any time?

Most pet insurance policies allow you to cancel, but the process and potential refunds can vary. Check with your insurance provider for their specific cancellation policy.

CONTACT US

If you have questions or comments – contact us online!

Subscribe for Newsletter

Stay always in touch! Subscribe to our newsletter.